PDA

View Full Version : Stephen Coughlin Sacked



SWJED
01-05-2008, 08:54 PM
From Bill Gertz's Inside the Ring (http://www.washingtontimes.com/article/20080104/NATION04/410150204/1008) at the Washington Tmes.


Stephen Coughlin, the Pentagon specialist on Islamic law and Islamist extremism, has been fired from his position on the military's Joint Staff. The action followed a report in this space last week revealing opposition to his work for the military by pro-Muslim officials within the office of Deputy Defense Secretary Gordon England.

Mr. Coughlin was notified this week that his contract with the Joint Staff will end in March, effectively halting the career of one of the U.S. government's most important figures in analyzing the nature of extremism and ultimately preparing to wage ideological war against it.

He had run afoul of a key aide to Mr. England, Hasham Islam, who confronted Mr. Coughlin during a meeting several weeks ago when Mr. Islam sought to have Mr. Coughlin soften his views on Islamist extremism.

Mr. Coughlin was accused directly by Mr. Islam of being a Christian zealot or extremist "with a pen," according to defense officials. Mr. Coughlin appears to have become one of the first casualties in the war of ideas with Islamism.

The officials said Mr. Coughlin was let go because he had become "too hot" or controversial within the Pentagon.

Misguided Pentagon officials, including Mr. Islam and Mr. England, have initiated an aggressive "outreach" program to U.S. Muslim groups that critics say is lending credibility to what has been identified as a budding support network for Islamist extremists, including front groups for the radical Muslim Brotherhood.

Mr. Coughlin wrote a memorandum several months ago based on documents made public in a federal trial in Dallas that revealed a covert plan by the Muslim Brotherhood, an Egyptian-origin Islamist extremist group, to subvert the United States using front groups. Members of one of the identified front groups, the Islamic Society of North America, has been hosted by Mr. England at the Pentagon...

Ron Humphrey
01-05-2008, 09:00 PM
From Bill Gertz's Inside the Ring (http://www.washingtontimes.com/article/20080104/NATION04/410150204/1008) at the Washington Tmes.

Where have I read an article written by Mr. Islam.

JeffC
01-05-2008, 09:20 PM
From Bill Gertz's Inside the Ring (http://www.washingtontimes.com/article/20080104/NATION04/410150204/1008) at the Washington Tmes.

As far as I'm concerned, this is a good sign, particularly in combination with the Pentagon's consideration of an Iraq "Marshall Plan". It means that they're abandoning the "Islam is evil" mindset that has pervaded the White House and the Pentagon for most of the war in favor of a more moderate position which includes reaching out to the vast moderate Muslim community; something that must happen if we are to win the Long War.

SWJED
01-05-2008, 09:40 PM
Eaton Agonistes, Redux? (http://www.andrewbostom.org/blog/2008/01/05/eaton-agonistes-redux/) - Andrew Bostom blog

"The termination of Stephen Coughlin on the Joint Staff is an act of intellectual cowardice" (http://www.jihadwatch.org/archives/019465.php) - Jihad Watch

Pentagon's Moderate Muslim Outreach Continues with Coughlin's Dismissal (http://idolator.typepad.com/intelfusion/2008/01/pentagons-moder.html) - Intel Fusion

Islam Says Submit at Pentagon (http://www.blackfive.net/main/2008/01/blackfive-tv--i.html) - Blackfive

Much More (http://blogsearch.google.com/blogsearch?hl=en&ie=UTF-8&tab=wb&q=stephen+Coughlin&scoring=d) - via Blogosphere

Stevely
01-06-2008, 01:47 AM
As far as I'm concerned, this is a good sign, particularly in combination with the Pentagon's consideration of an Iraq "Marshall Plan". It means that they're abandoning the "Islam is evil" mindset that has pervaded the White House and the Pentagon for most of the war in favor of a more moderate position which includes reaching out to the vast moderate Muslim community; something that must happen if we are to win the Long War.

In seven years I have not seen any evidence, whether in public statements or actual policy, that the government considers Islam evil and that such an attitude drives our strategy (however poor it is in other respects). They may be bad at "outreach" but the government in its clumsy way has been trying to show that the extremists are trying to hijack Islam and that we side with those moderates who want to live with the rest of the world in peace. For all the Bush Administration's sins, holding Islam at large as an enemy hasn't been one of them.

JeffC
01-06-2008, 04:02 AM
In seven years I have not seen any evidence, whether in public statements or actual policy, that the government considers Islam evil and that such an attitude drives our strategy (however poor it is in other respects). They may be bad at "outreach" but the government in its clumsy way has been trying to show that the extremists are trying to hijack Islam and that we side with those moderates who want to live with the rest of the world in peace. For all the Bush Administration's sins, holding Islam at large as an enemy hasn't been one of them.

I agree that the U.S. government has not adopted that as a formal position (thank goodness), however the belief that Islam is evil is held by some individuals working for the government, and those individuals, if placed high enough, can interfere with the process of finding workable solutions to this long-standing problem. Coughlin was one of those individuals. Another is LTC Joseph C. Meyers, Army advisor to the Commandant of the Air Command and Staff College, formerly with the DIA, and holder of the Medal of Achievement, awarded to him by the DNI.

Umar Al-Mokhtār
02-29-2008, 07:45 PM
JeffC doesn't read Sun Tzu. A little ditty about knowing your enemies.

In that vein: Hasham Islam = Kim Philby. Mayhaps?

Mad props to Blackfive.net for this juicy tid bit:

"The simple fact is that calling attention and shining a bright light on Islam around the world paints an ugly picture about a misogynistic, oppressive religion that has spawned a group of hellish murderers willing to kill their way to Paradise with Allah and the goats or here on Earth under the loving iron sandal of Sharia."

IMHO the US Government and GWB have almost adopted an ostrich position in regards to Muslim extremism and it fundmental core values.

Perhaps Hasham Islam is really Gordon England's avatar. Hmmmm. :eek: