all the biometric gizmos in the world
Hey Bill,
I second that. We recently discussed high tech and leaving our ground troops behind. In 1984, the Rangers in Sub-Sahara once said to me "you gotta put the troops in the mud where customs, culture and their meanings, real whether material or spiritual exist !"
Regards, Stan
Proven method to ID people
I would usually agree about the Tech solution except that automated fingerprinting identification is a proven TTP for population control. Criminals, bad guys in general hate being identified and or being kept track of. The only problem I see with the system is it could be misused by the Iraq police department without monitoring (example they collect info on people that they consider their enemy Sunni,Shia,Kurd,etc. while ignoring everyone else.)
GPS Chips and "red dots" on the screen
Slapout,
All of our EOD dogs have chips "somewhere". Yeah, the dogs cost upwards of 5 grand at only 8 weeks old, so more or less logical.
I have no doubt, that if we could do that to dogs years ago, who else had these "chips" installed :eek:
Hey, you're not gonna start the "stuffed animal" theory again ?
As for chips on shoulders; Hmmm....Naw, I just have a huge ego :D
Regards, Stan
Biometrics on the battlefield
The use of biometrics on the battlefield is not the end-all answer to the problems faced by our forces in Iraq or Afghanistan; I have seen several different types of systems used by various branches in different theatres, all with their own problems. From not being able to interface the databases, not having the troops to operate the systems, what type of information is collected, searching the database and classification of the types of information gathered. When it’s used properly it can be an excellent tool. I would think that how that information is used as well as how it’s disseminated is of much more importance. From a force protection standpoint having a database of foreign nationals that either attempt to access or have access to US/Coalition facilities is absolutely paramount. Personally I have seen where an individual has been denied access to one location for security reasons shown up and granted access to another, due to the fact there are differences in the screening techniques or lack thereof. Simply believing that a handheld device is the answer to all of your problems can be deadly, I have read repeatedly on the Small Wars Journal that winning COIN is not an overnight solution; I would say the same for using Biometrics as well. One would have to establish several databases with various checks/balances and interconnectivity. From the end users whom collect database, whether that’s a unit on patrol who comes across a person of interest, CA teams who interact with local political and religious leaders, troops embedded with host nation elements, MP training units designated to train police departments, HUMINT elements, Engineers that oversee projects both on and off installations, and the EPW/detainee situations. Obviously each element has certain particulars that they need to know and each type has overlying requirements. Nor would one want to turn over a list of all local nationals granted access to said installation to the local police/intelligence agency, so they could check the list against their suspected bad guys, if we as in US forces were to give out this information in essence we are giving the enemy the tools they need to defeat the checks. Using these tools is very helpful but only if the users are properly utilizing it. As far as procurement of the equipment I found that it was extremely easy, contacting the appropriate agency, CENTCOM has an element that’s purpose is to supply that to the units and will send trainers to them wherever they are, telling them what you are trying to do and they get it out fast. Too often I’ve heard the negative when it comes to the use of Biometrics especially from foreign nationals, and I’ve found that a lot of it traces back to the elements collecting it, instead of making it seem like a dire voodoo type of thing where the individuals feel that they might go to jail why not make everyone feel that its an honor or a privilege to have their information taken, hell give ‘em an ID card! From what I’ve seen no matter where I go someone comes up to me and has to either tell me or show me a letter or certificate they’ve received from the US. Well I don’t claim to know it all or even some but I know a lil bit, exactly about what I’m not sure. :eek: I hope you find something I’ve said useful or at least interesting.
here is a link to Trust but Identify: an introduction to department of defense automated biometric identification system
www.biometrics.dod.mil/documents/BRIEFS/Trust%20but%20Identify.pdf