How Pakistan (and Afghanistan) can fix itself
Interesting article in Foreign Affairs. The authors discuss the issue that Pakistan is a failed/failing state and provide recommendations on how to fix it. Most notable is the statistics on children NOT in school/employed and the correlation to suicide bombers and extremism. If they are correct, then Greg Mortenson's work is simply a drop in the bucket. They recommend Pakistan allow Nato-led PRTs.
v/r
Mike
How Pakistan can fix itself
By Ayesha Khanna, Parag Khanna
Quote:
Giving millions of mainstream Pakistanis a stake in the economy is the only way for the country to avert a deeper failure. A country in existential crisis does not have the luxury of separate education and labor policies. Twenty million children ages 10 to 17 are not in school, and of the almost 25 million Pakistanis ages 18 to 24, more than half have either not completed school or graduated but remain underemployed. Many in these poor and disenfranchised classes are listless young men; most suicide bombers are the 18- or 19-year-olds who come from their ranks.
The textbook approaches to supporting secondary education don't make sense unless the economy is geared toward employing the educated. So much international research and commentary on Pakistani education has focused on madrasa reform, ignoring the older portion of the population that most needs to be engaged. Vocational schools must get immediate funding to recruit and train able-bodied youth in basic engineering and construction work, and university students should be dispatched to participate in PRTs as well as "Teach for Pakistan" programs. There are many shura councils in the FATA, including even in North Waziristan, that have expressed a desire to receive outside assistance provided it works with them rather than around them.
Additionally, the Daily show had an interesting discussion last night as well.
Jon Stewart and Fareed Zakaria on Pakistan
Every day the U.S. learns more and more about less and less.
This quote from the link provided by Goesh:
Quote:
"On all fronts," said a senior U.S. official, "Hamid Karzai has plateaued as a leader."
is typical of the abysmal stupidity and oversized mouths of way too many in the Political class. Not to mention their inability to accept that such comments are not helpful -- even if you plan on withholding support.
Moving right along...
Pakistan has a major problem and that is the US -- and comments similar to that I quoted. If they knew the US was going to stick around and not let the Taliban again rule Afghanistan, they'd be a lot more cooperative. OTOH, given our abysmal track record of abandoning others to unkind fates (Viet Nam, Somalia, Kuwait, Iraq, Kurds and more) they are rightly concerned that we may get tired or bored and just leave -- then they'd have a Talib ruled state on their North flank.
We can't trust Pakistan to do what we want because they don't trust us to do what they want...
And idiots like that blabbermouthed Pol don't help...