French urban rioting (catch all)
Moderator's Note
Thread title was 'France's internal 'small war' (merged thread) and now 2nd May 2013 changed to French urban rioting (catch all), as distinct from political violence, terrorism etc. There are several threads on France / French matters: a catch all (including CT), the military and specific events. (ends).
Reuters: French Youths Turn to Web, Cellphones to Plan Riots. Excerpt follows:
"France's government is policing cyberspace as well as rundown suburbs in the battle to end two weeks of rioting."
"Young rioters are using blog messages to incite violence and cellphones to organize attacks in guerrilla-like tactics they have copied from anti-globalisation protesters, security experts say..."
Muslim rioters in France?
"Much of the world's attention over these two weeks has been on the role played by Islam. France is home to some 5m-6m Muslims, one-third of the total in the European Union and almost one-tenth of the country's population. Some French Muslims have been radicalised by such recent events as the September 11th terrorist attacks, the Iraq war (even though France opposed it) and the ban on wearing the Muslim headscarf in state schools (which was imposed in early 2004). Yet the French government has tried harder than many to integrate its Muslims, to create institutions to represent them, to work closely with imams and mosques, and to keep a wary eye on Islamic extremists. In any case, despite claims that the riots are France's intifada, they have not taken on a religious tinge. The rioters have not been the more devout Muslims; indeed, they include many non-Muslims." - The Economist, 10 Nov 05.
I see this issue being raised repeatedly in the Op-Ed pieces from the news links section of this site. Above is yet another quote on the issue from a well written magazine. This one, as do some others, directly refutes much of the reporting and opinionating in other sources by claiming that the rioting is NOT religiously motivated or based. So what's the opinion of the prestigious and august readership of this board? Religiously motivated or not? Is there an opportunity for Islamists to hijack the situation if it is not originally of their creation? If so, what could they accomplish? I dont see the Islamic Republic of France emerging from all this.
Paris is Burning, Yet Again ~
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/21978411/
"The violence was more intense than during three weeks of rioting in 2005, said the official, Patrice Ribeiro. Police were shot at and are facing "genuine urban guerillas with conventional weapons and hunting weapons.
Dozens of officers injured in Paris-area rioting
.............
At least 77 police injured during intense rioting by ‘genuine urban guerillas’
..............
Library set afire
Among the buildings targeted by the youths was a library, which was set afire.
.............
In Sunday's violence, eight people were arrested and 20 police officers were injured -- including the town's police chief, who was beaten in the face when he tried to negotiate with the rioters, police said. One firefighter also was injured. "
Not the Chief! Where is Napolean's famous whiff of grapeshot when needed most?
French suburbs turn away from state and towards Islam: scientist reports
Found via KoW a respected academic's report, on two suburbs of paris that exploded in rioting in 2005; which starts with:
Quote:
Local communities in France’s immigrant suburbs increasingly organize themselves on Islamic lines rather than following the values of the secular republic, according to a major new sociological study.
The resulting study − “Suburbs of the Republic” − found that religious institutions and practices are increasingly displacing those of the state and the French Republic, which has a strong secular tradition.
(Ends with) The author warns: “France’s future depends on its ability to re-integrate the suburbs into the national project.”
Link:http://english.alarabiya.net/article...06/170484.html
The actual report appears not to be available, for those interested the think tank's website is:http://www.institutmontaigne.org/site/page.php
French urban policing observed
A short article based on a new book:
Quote:
The following is an excerpt from Didier Fassin's Enforcing Order: An Ethnography of Urban Policing, a study conducted over 15 months of field work that depicts the hostile relationship between youths and police in riotous France. Fassin, an ethnographer, worked closely with anti-crime squads in one of the largest precincts in the Paris region to show a unique perspective into the lives of police tasked with enforcing social order in the name of public security.
Link:http://www.policeone.com/training/ar...volatile-city?
The French state has a long history of confronting dissent, protest and apparently what other LE agencies would call anti-social behavior. Their approach is far from 'community policing' as this passage shows:
Quote:
As to the relationship between the local population and law enforcement, it was consistently deteriorating. There were constant stops and frisks, always targeting the same young men, which had no effect on illegal activities but raised tensions. When a resident called the police about a mundane problem such as a noisy gathering in a square, the response was so brutal and, ultimately, counterproductive that most had given up making complaints.
The French Intifada: The Long War Between France and Its Arabs
A NYT review of a new book 'The French Intifada: The Long War Between France and Its Arabs' by Professor Andrew Hussey, a British academic based in Paris:http://www.nytimes.com/2014/06/29/bo...ssey.html?_r=0
Hard to find the best quote, so here is one passage:
Quote:
According to one finding, French Muslims make up the largest fraction of European jihadists in Syria. Hussey reports that Muslims are 70 percent of inmates in French prisons — an “engine room of Islamist radicalism.”
Is this a cultural or socioeconomic problem? Hussey argues skillfully against commentators who reduce all discontents to poverty. Both economic and #cultural factors are surely at play. France has struggled with obdurate unemployment rates for a long time, yet the globalization of aggressive Islamic radicalism in past decades merits no less consideration.
Link to Amazon, note it is possible to order via SWJ and so it gets a commission:http://www.amazon.com/French-Intifada-Between-France-Arabs/dp/0865479216/ref=sr_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1404069004&sr=1-1&keywords=andrew+hussey+the+french+intifada
http://www.amazon.co.uk/French-Intif...rench+intifada
The French intifada: France and its Muslims
This time a left-wing reviewer, a former (disgraced) Labour MP and he starts with:
Quote:
Andrew Hussey’s (book) on France, its Muslim population and the challenge of Islamism—is the most interesting book about France to have been published in English for many years.
Apparently Hussey is ready to say the unthinkable, e.g. regarding a French colonial hero, Marshal Hubert Lyautey, French Governor General of Morocco for the first quarter of the 20th century:
Quote:
this highly regarded French statesman-soldier was a prolific sodomite and paedophile who buggered everyone from his military aides-de-camp to passing Arab urchins.
Link:http://www.prospectmagazine.co.uk/ar...nd-its-muslims
The French Intifada by Andrew Hussey
Finally got to read my copy and really pleased I did. Most of the book is a succinct history of France's bloody colonisation of North Africa (Morocco, Tunisia and Algeria mainly).
The urban "hotspots" for tension and bouts of rioting known as the banlieues. The author has a key passage explaining why:
Quote:
There is a lot of anger and a lot of young men willing to turn themselves into Soldiers for God. Most importantly, the rioters, wreckers, even the killers of the banlieues are not looking for reform or revolution. They are looking for revenge.
The Other France: Are the suburbs of Paris incubators of terrorism?
A long New Yorker article, presumably in preparation till the Thalys train attack; in places pessimsitic and then optimistic:http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/20...e-other-france
Interesting passages on what is happening in French prisons.
After a police 'rape' "they" are looking for revenge.
Scarcely believable:
Quote:
Protests have broken out in Paris’s economically-deprived outskirts (the banlieues) in recent weeks, some of which have degenerated into
riots. The unrest was sparked by a shocking case of alleged police brutality in which a 22-year-old black man was allegedly set upon by four police officers in the north-eastern suburb of Aulnay-sous-Bois. Now one of those officers is under investigation for rape.
One of the officers has now been charged with rape, having been accused of thrusting a truncheon into Théo’s anus while he was on the ground, causing
severe injuries. The officer maintains that Théo’s injury happened
accidentally and an initial investigation by the police
reportedly found there was “insufficient evidence” to support the claim that it was a deliberate act.
Link:https://theconversation.com/a-horrific-accusation-against-police-reignites-anger-in-paris-suburbs-73314?
An earlier BBC report:http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-38957953