Afghanistan, Democracy, and GDP
This is an open question in two parts; 1) Is it possible for Afghanistan to reach the threshold per capita GDP that political scientists feel is required for sustaining a democracy, and 2) If not, what form of government should the international community be promoting in Afghanistan?
A little background from a recent news release. This article dealt with predictions of the potential for China to transition to democracy, but the GDP numbers are what are important.
"China's grassroots progress toward democracy is comparable to that which took place in the early 1970s in Taiwan, when per capita income reached about $2,500, similar to China's income today, Rowen writes.
"The worldwide norm, first clearly established by [Stanford Professor Emeritus] Seymour Martin Lipset, is 'the richer the country, the freer,' '' Rowen writes, although he also notes that Saudi Arabia and Brunei, countries enriched through oil, have not followed that pattern.
"Growing wealth is accompanied by increased education, the building of business and government institutions with some autonomy, and the formation of attitudes that enable democratic governments to survive when they have a chance at power," he said. If China's economic growth continues at today's rates, it will reach mean incomes of $7,000 to $8,000 by 2015. "Spain, Portugal, Chile and Argentina, in addition to Taiwan and South Korea, all made the transition to democracy while they were within this income range."
http://news-service.stanford.edu/pr/96/961115china.html
According to the CIA World Fact Book, Afghanistan's GDP is about $1,000. Given this information, and granted it is only one of several factors to consider in democratic development, can Afghanistan reach the $2,500 threshold let alone $7-8K? If not, what options are available?
Afghanistan, India, Mozambique...
Quote:
Originally Posted by
TheCurmudgeon
This is an open question in two parts; 1) Is it possible for Afghanistan to reach the threshold per capita GDP that political scientists feel is required for sustaining a democracy, and 2) If not, what form of government should the international community be promoting in Afghanistan?
There is certainly a strong correlation between democracy and GDP/capita—however, it is just that, a correlation. There is no requirement—if there was, India wouldn't have sustained a democratic polity since 1947 (current PPP GDP/capita, approximately $2,700).
Indeed, quantitative studies that test correlates of democracy typically code India as a single case, on a par with, say, Vanuatu. If you weight it by population (1 billion), then the income/democracy relationship is far less clear.
More to the point, it is worth considering the case of Mozambique: despite poverty and 17 years of brutal civil war (almost 1 million dead, around 5% of the population), it has sustained imperfect democratic politics since the 1994 elections.
(Full credit to the UN, and more particularly the then SRSG Aldo Ajello, for managing a very tricky transition.)
Afghanistan: a place to test a theory?
Afghanistan has long been a "basket case" economy, with little of value to export (note how little is said about the natural gas production in the north) and I exclude heroin. In the early years of the Cold War there was competition between the USA and USSR in providing aid; for the road network and irrigation in Helmand Province for example. Has the economy really improved since the USSR's invasion? Let alone the latest Western intervention?
Not a good place to test an economic theory IMO.
davidbfpo
Not a good place to test it
Quote:
Originally Posted by
davidbfpo
Afghanistan has long been a "basket case" economy, with little of value to export (note how little is said about the natural gas production in the north) and I exclude heroin. In the early years of the Cold War there was competition between the USA and USSR in providing aid; for the road network and irrigation in Helmand Province for example. Has the economy really improved since the USSR's invasion? Let alone the latest Western intervention?
Not a good place to test an economic theory IMO.
davidbfpo
Or not a good place to expect something like that to work?