Search:

Type: Posts; User: Charles Martel; Keyword(s):

Search: Search took 0.03 seconds.

  1. Replies
    96
    Views
    136,163

    The problem is a focus on briefings instead of discussion and direction

    Many on this forum have correctly identified that it is lazy thinking, not PowerPoint, that is the problem. PowerPoint is the symptom. The underlying problem is the way we train commanders to sit...
  2. Replies
    50
    Views
    116,283

    True, but it has to be both

    We have to do both, push the governments that restrict human rights and opportunity (pick any gov't in the Middle East as a prime example) to change as well as deradicalize the environment. Radical...
  3. Replies
    68
    Views
    49,452

    Tequila, I feel about IO like Ghandi felt...

    Tequila,

    I feel about IO like Ghandi felt about Christianity: [it is] a good thing but it needed people to try it. We don't even make the attempt at pointing out the inhumanity of our enemies and...
  4. Replies
    68
    Views
    49,452

    It isn't either/or

    I've never thought that these decisions are either save lives or save image. The actions and words should be integrated so as to reinforce each other and do both.

    We know that AQ has been trying...
  5. Replies
    68
    Views
    49,452

    Bill, I would agree on the security issue...

    Bill,

    I would agree on the security issue before 1983, but since then the Embassies have become more and more like fortresses. There are ways for the Ambassador to protect his folks without...
  6. Replies
    68
    Views
    49,452

    We might make them mad

    No troops for Yemen: White House aide (AFP) 3 January 2010, http://tinyurl.com/y8d459z

    Do we really need to announce this? Might be the right answer if YM can defeat AQ with only indirect support...
  7. Replies
    68
    Views
    49,452

    Not saying that the YM government is worth...

    Not saying that the YM government is worth backing. If they have truly had enough of AQ and take up arms against it, it's a good start, however. My point is that we should think through the impact...
  8. Replies
    84
    Views
    62,168

    Are we caving to AQ threats?

    Sure seems like it when we close our Embassy in Yemen and announce that it was due to fears of AQ retaliation for our support of the Yemeni government (http://tinyurl.com/y9mhuxb).

    Strategic...
  9. Replies
    68
    Views
    49,452

    Are we caving to AQ threats?

    Sure seems like it when we close our Embassy in Yemen and announce that it was due to fears of AQ retaliation for our support of the Yemeni government (http://tinyurl.com/y9mhuxb).

    Strategic...
  10. Doubtful that we'll see irrevocable changes

    Wish I could be more optimistic, but the Iranian regime will lash out violently at any hint of real rebellion. Our best course is to support democracy against tyranny and let the world draw their...
  11. Need confirmation

    Absolutely agree. We'll see if other sources confirm.
  12. Iranian Mutiny?

    PJMedia is reporting that a letter of support for the protesters signed by Commanders in the Iranian Army. The text of the report can be found at:...
  13. Just one more example of why we need to engage the media more

    I never ascribe to guile that which can be written off to ignorance. That said, the only way to stop this sort of idiocy is to do more to educate the media. However, most military officers have an...
  14. Poll: Moral Equivalency is Mental Indolence

    Saying that all cultures are morally equivalent is to not think about the underlying question at all. There are God-given rights that, if violated, make a culture less worthy than others that...
  15. Replies
    56
    Views
    47,882

    How dumb

    The writer's woolly-headedness is evident when he uses the "supposed success of the surge [in Iraq]" to denigrate GEN P's previous accomplishments then argues that previous success are not indicative...
  16. Although I was ready to be surprised, I'm not

    This is the DoS press release that explains that the State Department is going to use military reservists because it can't fill the 250 slots it has in Afghanistan. It says it is "essential" to have...
  17. Replies
    32
    Views
    38,296

    Why don't we codify what we are learning in our real "Battle Labs"?

    The S/G/J-3's coordinate Eng, Arty, Avn, AD, etc, but we take what is their most important tool in COIN and place it in a parallel staff section -- the 7. If we really believe that information ops...
  18. I'm fully prepared to be wrong

    Let's hope that I am. When the non-military agencies start flowing in to fix what the President says is the most important challenge we face as a nation, I will be the happiest guy around. Just...
  19. Can't ignore the fact that DoS has not stepped up

    Bruce,

    The career FSOs bleating about being sent "to their deaths" in Iraq when it looked like volunteers wouldn't fill the numbers weren't media hype. There are lots of skills that FSOs have...
  20. How do we say the Afghan Surge is not just mil when civilians are not participating?

    Looked at the new plan for Afghanistan and there is lots of rhetoric about rebuilding, governance, rule of law, etc, but the latest DoS statements indicate that very few civilians are actually being...
Results 1 to 20 of 22