Search:

Type: Posts; User: Steve Blair; Keyword(s):

Search: Search took 0.04 seconds.

  1. Replies
    317
    Views
    326,438

    Slap...most of Warden's doctrinal ideas can be...

    Slap...most of Warden's doctrinal ideas can be traced directly to the Luftwaffe's doctrine of 1936. He also ignores the fact that airpower cannot control terrain, secure a population, or do any...
  2. Replies
    317
    Views
    326,438

    There are some valuable parts to Warden's stuff,...

    There are some valuable parts to Warden's stuff, but his biggest shortcoming is that he sees airpower as capable of doing EVERYTHING on its own and being applicable in every situation...even when...
  3. Replies
    317
    Views
    326,438

    Sorry, slap...that's just Warden trying to make...

    Sorry, slap...that's just Warden trying to make his preferred solution relevant even when it isn't. ISIS is still a relatively irregular foe, and according to Colin Gray's informative (if...
  4. Replies
    317
    Views
    326,438

    Very much agree!

    Very much agree!
  5. Replies
    317
    Views
    326,438

    Warden's use of the Luftwaffe to illustrate his...

    Warden's use of the Luftwaffe to illustrate his examples is one of the points (IMO) where he really goes off the rails. The Luftwaffe did exactly what it was designed to do, because the Germans had a...
  6. Replies
    317
    Views
    326,438

    Warden is also terrible when it comes to using...

    Warden is also terrible when it comes to using historical examples to "prove" his points. His "The Air Campaign" is riddled with poor examples and things massaged to fit. His guide is flawed in that...
  7. Replies
    317
    Views
    326,438

    Not much to add to this one. Warden for me is...

    Not much to add to this one. Warden for me is something of a one-track recording. You need airpower in some situations, just like you need any sort of combat power. IMO our own LawVol did a much...
Results 1 to 7 of 7