Search:

Type: Posts; User: jmm99; Keyword(s):

Search: Search took 0.10 seconds.

  1. Replies
    137
    Views
    340,536

    Nice Catch, Ted

    Thank you.

    Cheers

    Mike
  2. Replies
    137
    Views
    340,536

    Hey Wilf,

    I'm not a novelist, but I'll try to flesh out our imaginary journey into small war land. I am putting some parameters on this: we're both indigenous to Country X and no foreign elements are involved...
  3. Replies
    137
    Views
    340,536

    Your points

    at the end:



    with triple emphasis on "I do not" (B, I and U ;)); and also this:



    do clarify to me your position re: the military effort and the political effort.
  4. Replies
    137
    Views
    340,536

    Context, context and context

    Fine with me.

    1. Criminals are not in the same context as insurgents. However, taking criminals as an example, you (if you happen to be in criminal justice) want a great deal of co-operation from...
  5. Replies
    137
    Views
    340,536

    A mix of agree and disagree

    1. Isolating the population may work if the facts allow it (as in Malaya, where a minority of a minority were isolated from the bush-based guerrillas). If the insurgents permeate the entire...
  6. Replies
    137
    Views
    340,536

    Lost opportunity costs

    My belief is that both Algeria and Vietnam were decided that way.

    Regards

    Mike
  7. Replies
    137
    Views
    340,536

    Good question, JMA

    First off, the soldier's Powers That Be should adopt a clear set of non-conflicting military operational considerations, diplomatic-political policies and legal constraints. As to legal, one must...
  8. Replies
    137
    Views
    340,536

    War Casualties

    The Algerian War - Wiki has Wilf's 28K KIA + 60K WIA for the French. On the FLN side of the ledger, this:



    with a longer story in the Wiki's Death Toll section:



    Unscrambling all those...
  9. Replies
    137
    Views
    340,536

    Reason for cutting Algeria loose

    No doubt "war weariness" contributed to DG's decision (Wilf's point); BUT probably more important was the cost of lost opportunities elsewhere if Algeria continued to be a drain financially, and on...
  10. Replies
    137
    Views
    340,536

    Animals vs bad humans

    This is totally a personal thought - and not an argument vs anyone who thinks differently. Anyway, as to this:



    I've always liked animals. They act from instinct; and, though nature is very red...
  11. Replies
    137
    Views
    340,536

    Reciprocity

    First off, I reject "relative filth" as a legal defense; but, at the same time, have to acknowledge its practical uses in some areas (e.g., divorce cases).

    Once upon a time, though, reciprocity...
  12. Replies
    137
    Views
    340,536

    Torture and interrogation

    I'm on record here at SWC as being a "softie" on interrogation (Comments on methodology) - and like Jedburgh (here), I am more impressed by brains over brawn methodologies in this area (here and...
Results 1 to 12 of 12