Search:

Type: Posts; User: Bob's World; Keyword(s):

Page 1 of 2 1 2

Search: Search took 0.11 seconds.

  1. Replies
    278
    Views
    720,218

    The US founders were not deprived either, but...

    The US founders were not deprived either, but they burned at the disrespect levied against them their fellow British citizens who officially and in practice deemed Colonists inferior due merely for...
  2. Replies
    278
    Views
    720,218

    We need to appreciate the powerful effect of the...

    We need to appreciate the powerful effect of the identity-based populations that every person has. If a person identifies with some issue or cause, they become a member of a distributed population...
  3. Replies
    278
    Views
    720,218

    The ideology has been there for 15 years, but now...

    The ideology has been there for 15 years, but now suddenly 20,000 pack up and go.

    Is it so hard to accept that it is the mission that is the draw, and not the message?

    I think Western egos can...
  4. Replies
    278
    Views
    720,218

    The greasegun is a super cheap .45 cal submachine...

    The greasegun is a super cheap .45 cal submachine gun developed by the US to arm revolutionary and resistance fighters with who's actions we thought would advance our interests. We did not...
  5. Replies
    278
    Views
    720,218

    So, just curious, what percentage of American...

    So, just curious, what percentage of American colonists in support of revolution were "radicalized" by the words of Sam Adams and Thomas Paine; versus those who were radicalized by the actions of...
  6. Replies
    278
    Views
    720,218

    The demands of the vocal few rarely reflect the...

    The demands of the vocal few rarely reflect the reasonable concerns of the groups the claim to represent. One must look past the noise to hear the sounds that really matter. One also must attempt...
  7. Replies
    278
    Views
    720,218

    David, the type of self determination we are...

    David, the type of self determination we are talking about among disaffected European Muslims is not that of a nation of people seeking governance determined by themselves rather than some foreign,...
  8. Replies
    278
    Views
    720,218

    Why any individual is motivated to join the USMC...

    Why any individual is motivated to join the USMC is not why the USMC exists.

    Why the USMC is employed to address any particular problem is not why the USMC exists.

    To understand why the USMC...
  9. Replies
    278
    Views
    720,218

    David, I would offer that...

    David,

    I would offer that "de-radicalization" is not a successful solution to terrorism simply because "radicalization" is not the cause of terrorism.

    Terrorism is a political weapon...
  10. Replies
    278
    Views
    720,218

    Ok, fair enough, let's explore this niche of...

    Ok, fair enough, let's explore this niche of "ethnic terrorism."

    Is this just pure racist violence for the sake of hate, or for some political purpose?

    I'm no expert on what the KKK is today,...
  11. Replies
    278
    Views
    720,218

    #1 radicalizer of insurgents or terrorists? ...

    #1 radicalizer of insurgents or terrorists? Government.

    Everything else is just lubrication and nudges to move those radicals in the direction of one organization or another.
  12. Replies
    278
    Views
    720,218

    It is well to consider that behind the ideologies...

    It is well to consider that behind the ideologies of "communisim" that U.S. foreign policy shifted to containing upon the fall of Nationalist China were always vast popular movements in the pursuit...
  13. Replies
    278
    Views
    720,218

    The best COIN is "prevent" and is performed by...

    The best COIN is "prevent" and is performed by civil government in stable countries and communities around the world everyday. Those who neglect true prevent inevitably find themselves soon mired in...
  14. Replies
    278
    Views
    720,218

    Radicalization is a grossly overblown concept. ...

    Radicalization is a grossly overblown concept. It's part of the victim mentality that is so common among officials faced with insurgency, or even terrorist attacks.

    Are some out there actually...
  15. Replies
    278
    Views
    720,218

    Nothing wrong with an ounce of prevention, so long as it is properly directed

    The entire concept of "radicalization" is premised in the flawed construct that good citizens go bad due solely to outside influence. Prevention seems to have been focused at these bad outside...
  16. Replies
    278
    Views
    720,218

    Welcome to Bob's World

    You call something a war, and you will treat it like war.

    You call someone a terrorist and you will conduct counterterrorism against them.

    You go to a foreign country and claim that your own...
  17. Replies
    278
    Views
    720,218

    There is nothing new under the sun...

    Give me a day or two and I'll put something up.
  18. Replies
    278
    Views
    720,218

    You all have been making me think about why I think this today

    Which, of course, is why I take tactical pauses to post. So here goes:

    As I have stated fairly often, when it comes to insurgency it's all about the perception of the insurgent populace. ...
  19. Replies
    278
    Views
    720,218

    "COIN" is number 2 on my hit list.

    CNAS would be number 3...but they are protected by the Constitution so I leave them on.:D
  20. Replies
    278
    Views
    720,218

    Don't worry, you are in good company

    Not a company I will join, but that is both of our perogatives.

    Most see ideology as a COG for insurgency; I, like Chairman Deng Xiaoping, see it much more as a Critical Requireiment. A good cat...
  21. Replies
    278
    Views
    720,218

    Be sure to add the chapter about Protestantism

    You wouldn't want to have us radical Christians feeling left out simply because our movement to throw off the poor governance of the Holy Roman Empire is already over.

    But if you are looking for...
  22. Replies
    278
    Views
    720,218

    Agreed. But I don't think COIN is war.

    Violent, no doubt.

    But given the inherent internal nature of insurgency and COIN, I am currently of the mind that calling it "war" is extremely counterproductive to effective COIN. Better to look...
  23. Replies
    278
    Views
    720,218

    "I have yet to see any evidence that either...

    "I have yet to see any evidence that either foreign fighters or AQ terrorists act as "members of insurgencies", unless we are to embrace the "global insurgency" notion, which I personally find...
  24. Replies
    278
    Views
    720,218

    Fair observations all.

    Equally fair though is to point out that "containment" was very simple in concept, yet very complex and evolving in execution. Same applies to thories that I offer up as being more relevant to...
  25. Replies
    278
    Views
    720,218

    And...

    I'll save my constructive comments on what SOCOM does well or poorly for when I have those conversations with the leadership there. They know they can count on me for a candid, thoughtful...
Results 1 to 25 of 39
Page 1 of 2 1 2