Search:

Type: Posts; User: Ken White; Keyword(s):

Search: Search took 0.05 seconds.

  1. Replies
    293
    Views
    807,353

    Not to intrude but though war is war, this is truth:

    This is likely true:This could also be true if the west does not awaken...We have a brief window and we'd better take advantage of it...
  2. Replies
    293
    Views
    807,353

    Not me, Anybody can use an atlatl

    and take my thumb off before I can cock my SAA, I ain't messin' with. Not to mention I don't run, dodge and jump so well nowadays. :D

    Or that with my luck, I'd be the second Neanderthal in line...
  3. Replies
    293
    Views
    807,353

    They're out there

    And, yeah, it sure looks hybrid...:rolleyes:
    LINK
  4. Replies
    293
    Views
    807,353

    Means to an end...

    Quoth Slap:Practically and semantically, I agree and think most would do so. In the politico-military context though, the issue become who decides the "how." Many moons ago, Lincoln gave Grant the...
  5. Replies
    293
    Views
    807,353

    Yes but I think you two are inadvertently talking past each other.

    I agree that Bob's World continually sallies into the political realm (the SO community does that quite often, I think it's it's probably genetic -- and one reason I left that commune... ;) ) and...
  6. Replies
    293
    Views
    807,353

    I don't understand the airpower versus

    9/11 point. What does one have to do with the other?

    Also, I see you posted his 3d conclusion -- what is wrong with it?
  7. Replies
    293
    Views
    807,353

    Good post, Bill.

    Agree. I don't see the Paper as anything other than a balanced view and a cautionary to folks not to get air power or land power centric...
  8. Replies
    293
    Views
    807,353

    That's not true.

    The Marines and US Army Light Infantry units adapted and adjusted and did it fairly well as did the Air Force. Only the dominant Heavy Division guys in the Army didn't adapt -- not because they...
  9. Replies
    293
    Views
    807,353

    I have a spurious comment and serious question.

    This brought to mind the fact that everyone doesn't say that; some, for example say "Treat 'em rough." and there are a host of other mandatory unit greetings, each as valid as the other. I have said...
  10. Replies
    293
    Views
    807,353

    Not fluff and a good article overall,

    however, my cynicism is based on more years watching the circus than I probably had a right to -- certainly more than I ever expected. ;)

    He's just playing the game and being smart about while...
  11. Replies
    293
    Views
    807,353

    It's QDR and New Administration time...

    Thus the spate of SOCOM articles touting the troops. :cool:

    That article's long on attaboys and short on specifics. Shaping, Shaping the battlefield..
  12. Replies
    293
    Views
    807,353

    Hybrid or Hijacked (our doctrine, that is...)

    Wilf said:He's charitable. It's pretty pathetic IMO overall, there is an occasional bright spot in the journals but they're rare. Most articles tend to be too scholarly for practical use. Footnote...
  13. Replies
    293
    Views
    807,353

    I think it's a combination of semantics and perceptions

    My take also...1. I think that US tactical and operational thinking has been so severely constrained by our fetish with 'metrics' and providing 'systems' thinking that we see anything out of OUR now...
  14. Replies
    293
    Views
    807,353

    Hmm...

    Hybrid warfare? Those pesky Steppe dwellers and the Egyptians invented Composite Bows. Then there was the thought "Let's distribute blankets from smallpox victims" ...
  15. Replies
    293
    Views
    807,353

    When the strategy is simply to continue to

    survive, doing things right tactically and operationally are pretty important -- one error can mean disaster.

    Which does not at all mean the Israelis did not profit strategically from the...
  16. Replies
    293
    Views
    807,353

    Thanks for posting that also,

    Cav Guy. Read his book a long time ago; agreed with parts and not with others. I do strongly agree with this statement of his you quote:Anyone who agrees with me is bound to be thinking...
  17. Replies
    293
    Views
    807,353

    Good post, Bob.

    True -- and regrettable, it's not that hard IMO. But that always seems to be the case; that they're behind the power curve. In my view that derives from trying to make too many disparate groups...
  18. Replies
    293
    Views
    807,353

    Well, obviously Colonel Macgrogor

    gets it. Fads don't matter. As he points out, WW II was absolutely full of 'hybrid' war. So were some segments in Korea and many segments in Viet Nam -- most, even.

    The only thing Hezbollah...
  19. Replies
    293
    Views
    807,353

    That's why I'm not a sports fan, Rob

    Folks are always changing the rules and in discussions, there are always "well, if..." things thrown in. None of those things you posit happened to get to this point: This did happen:With the last...
  20. Replies
    293
    Views
    807,353

    WM, I think

    you've got it pegged...
  21. Replies
    293
    Views
    807,353

    War *is* war -- but the rules change...

    So do the players.

    Unfortunately, we don't get to choose what type(s) of war we'll be involved in and any attempt to concentrate on one spectrum or another would be quite foolish. The "only big...
  22. Replies
    293
    Views
    807,353

    Hmbc5.5gw

    Mike Innes said:That coincides with my thoughts. There are good ideas in both papers but IMO, neither really surfaces anything new (unless I missed something, always possible :o), they've just...
  23. Replies
    293
    Views
    807,353

    War is a serious business.

    As we all know. Therefor, it seems to me that it is incumbent on everyone who engages in warfare at any level, from the politician who sends units forth to the last Snuffy (yes, even him...) to read...
Results 1 to 23 of 23