Here's BBC's take on it: link.
Here's BBC's take on it: link.
"On the plains and mountains of the American West, the United States Army had once learned everything there was to learn about hit-and-run tactics and guerrilla warfare."
T.R. Fehrenbach This Kind of War
If true a scandal and weakened IMO by the off-record media exposure.
Politically the UK government would not return troops to street fighting in Basra, after all we wanted out from that hellhole; yes, one we helped make it that.
How the UK government managed to hide the alleged agreement and related decisions from our closest ally is unclear.
Murky. How this story resonates here is unclear, maybe I will comment another day.
Here is the comment in The Daily Telegraph, with HMG and Opposition comments: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/news...-in-Basra.html
davidbfpo
Last edited by davidbfpo; 08-05-2008 at 08:49 PM. Reason: Add newspaper link.
six months ago in the media. I didn't think much about it at the time because that's been a British (and others, including us [rarely] and the French and Germans [frequently].) technique for many score years -- and allegedly MI6 / SIS or whoever they are today had just done the same thing not long before in Helmand, Afghanistan.
My recollection in the latter case is that Dan McNeill blew the whistle on the deal...
If true, a perfect example of field commanders findings themselves having to look over their shoulder because their Government has no real will to win the war, just to appear to fall into line with U.S. policy.
I started a SWJ Blog roundup post and will keep it updated as more of this story unfolds.
Patmc - I stole your title - thanks and a hat tip.
Policy, Ken? Somethin' that politicians create and soldiers try not to look at for fear of what they may see? That is, when policy is not "hear no evil, see no evil, speak no evil"?
carl wrote:
Shades of the Quartering Act! - Oh wait, at least the Brits paid for that priviledge in Basra. Seems to have had almost the same result though - I still doubt the Redcoats would be overly welcome in Boston, and it's been more than 200 years...Ms Ali was also unimpressed, describing the British troops as lodgers.
"I still doubt the Redcoats would be overly welcome in Boston, and it's been more than 200 years..."
Oh, I don't know. As long as they didn't wear a uniform on St. Patrick's Day I think they would ok. In any event, New York is just down the road and Royal Navy sailors thought that was a great liberty port in WWII.
"We fight, get beat, rise, and fight again." Gen. Nathanael Greene
The effect of British policy on Iraqi public opinion should be considered too. If the following quote from a TimesOnLine story is in any way typical of that opinion, the policy has been a disaster.
'He had less of a glowing impression of the British military, which had control of security in Basra from March 2003 until December 2007, a period that saw the al-Mehdi Army militia grow in strength and influence.
"British forces did not make an impression on the people of Basra. They let the militia control the city and stayed away from events."
Ms Ali was also unimpressed, describing the British troops as lodgers.
"As we know, people who rent stay away from trouble even if it is harming the house he has rented," she said.
"In my personal opinion, although I have no expertise, the US forces always want to appear strong and able to succeed in any battle. They will never allow militias to ruin the reputation of the US army."'
"We fight, get beat, rise, and fight again." Gen. Nathanael Greene
Bookmarks