Quote Originally Posted by Ski View Post
Thanks for the link, I have found Cordesman to be one of the most honest and realistic observers of the wars of the early 21st Century
...and I used to agree with that, till I saw these slides. While what he writes is vastly more accurate than I have seen in most open sources, there are some omissions, and some mistakes that indicate that this may have been a bit of a "rush job."

For example, the IDF had working examples of every ATGM and AT weapon they encountered in the Lebanon, prior to the war. They weren't "got by Military intelligence". They just went out on the market and brought them.

The statement "swarming works" indicates a lack of tactical and operational understanding and I don't think he would ever make that comment to a professional military audience.

IMO, the J.P. Storr article in the RUSI journal remains the most accurate and measured assessment of the ground war.