The Rules - Engaging HVTs & OBL

[jmm99]

re: this -

from Entropy
So does the AUMF trump the indictment? Or, since the indictment still exists can the President decide which "tool" to use based on his own judgment? In other words, was the decision to try to kill UBL or arrest UBL ultimately a policy decision and not a legal decision?

except for the "extra" CIA stuff - so, this chart still holds as the current USG position (expressly affirmed as to detention by the DC Circuit in many cases; implicitly, those decision affirm the kill option under the AUMF):

TVNSA Flow Chart 2011.jpg

The red boxes are a combo CIA-DoD effort (Title 50 + Title 10) - a kill result obviously goes no further.

If a capture, with CIA as lead, the agency now has to hand off detention to either DoJ (indictment) or DoD (detention only or military commission trial). As we have seen, these folks can be bounced back and forth between DoJ and DoD. Follow the blue arrows and lines.

Ah, what a Powerpoint Ranger I would have made

Good question. The simple answer is that everything is a Presidential policy decision, with some Congressional oversight.

I'll do the opposing view later.

Regards

Mike