Results 1 to 20 of 116

Thread: We need less Chemo and Surgery and more "Voom."

Threaded View

Previous Post Previous Post   Next Post Next Post
  1. #3
    Council Member
    Join Date
    May 2008
    Posts
    4,021

    Thumbs down To hell with metaphors

    whether cancer, cats in hats, etc., etc.

    We would do better to couch our assertions within the broad conventional frameworks, even if those assertions contain outrageously unconventional strategies and tactics.

    The term "fight" has no real meaning in this thread's context. A "War" (armed conflict) Paradigm has meaning. A non-War Paradigm also has meaning; but is more limiting in what strategies and tactics are available.

    End rant.

    BTW, these (except 4, which is a "don't"):

    from Dayuhan

    1. Defend effectively. Monitoring, tracking, infiltrating, and disrupting plots won't eliminate the antagonists, but it can minimize their impact, deprive them of high profile success, and isolate them from supporters who want to see results.

    2. Attack effectively. Find and eliminate the key individuals on the operational and the funding/support side by whatever means work.

    3. Starve them. Don't occupy territory, don't feed that "expel the infidel from the land of the faithful" narrative. Extended occupations of Muslim territory provide a discrete, specific target for jihadi propaganda and fundraising and should be avoided. We'll never convert the inner circle, they have to be killed, arrested, or driven so far underground that they can't operate. The inner circle can be isolated from their sources of support and recruitment.

    4. Don't be stupid. There will always someone who will tell us that the cause of all the mess is bad governance in Muslim countries and we can fix the mess by fixing governance in Muslim countries. Trying to do that is just going to get us deeper in the $#!t. It can be argued (though often exaggerated) that the bad governance problem is to some extent something we helped create, but we can't undo the effect of meddling past by meddling again.
    are within the War Paradigm (the USA position); but questionable under the non-War Paradigm (EU and UN positions).

    Note also that the War Paradigm is not limited to the SW quadrant of this matrix (JMM added Tangible = "military struggle" and Abstract = "political struggle"; though various "non-violent", "political" actions can be very "tangible"):

    Lwin CG Matrix - Fig 2.jpg

    from 1997 Lwin (thesis), Great States, Weak States & Assymetric Strategies.pdf (then a CPT, now a COL).

    Regards

    Mike
    Last edited by jmm99; 11-21-2012 at 10:59 PM.

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •