Quote Originally Posted by JWing View Post
Yesterday didn't have time to mention this but I published another interview. This time I talked with Paul Brinkley former Deputy Undersecretary of Defense who worked on economic development and Iraq & now CEO of North America Western Asia Holdings a major investor in Iraq. Brinkley was working in Iraq during the fall of Mosul. He discusses what Iraq was like during the summer of 2014, what were some of the political and economic issues that led to the return of the insurgency, and how U.S. policy went wrong in the country. Read the interview here.
Thanks for sharing this interview, it is worthy of posting on the SWJ Blog. The whole interview was informative relative Iraq, but his discussion on our desire to establish democracies where there robust middle classes do not exist is a point that has application well beyond our efforts in Iraq.

Since 9/11, US policy in the region has been focused on the notion that establishing democratic institutions via elections among oppressed and underdeveloped populations will lead to stability, and reduce the appeal of radical Islamist movements.

But democracies emerge from the presence of a vibrant middle class – an economically prosperous majority of a population that has a stake in stability and that demands a seat at the table in governing their own affairs. Throughout history it is almost impossible to find a successful democratic state with liberal institutions that lacks a vibrant middle class as a foundation on which democratic governance rests. American democracy is no exception – our institutions today would not survive without our own generally prosperous middle class.

Our foreign policy continues to ignore this necessity, in spite of repeated failures in efforts to establish democratic government via force (Iraq, Afghanistan, Libya), diplomacy (Sudan), or shifts in alignment of strategic support (Egypt) away from a former dictatorial ally. We still believe that elections are the primary building block to a stable prospering society.