I put together a powerpoint slide of Ninewa from 1950s to today, showing the many provincial, district, and subdistrict changes.
One slide with about 10 major layers. Te;lls the whole story in a minute.
It is consolidated from a huge amount of field research on the ground, and through provincial and ministerial governments. Collecting maps. Legislative enactments, governmental service boundary maps, etc... Dahuk (KRG) carved out in the north, Shirqat transferred to Salah ad Din (formerly Baghdad Province). The abolition of desert provinces, which brought Hatra and Ba'aj districts in. The disection of Irbil, which shifted Mahkmour to Ninewa, and other districts to Tam'im. Then, the internal re-disections of districts and sub-districts. Just in one province. Incredible.
I learned a while ago not to cast pearls before swine. NGA is great for geo-physical analysis, but his no capacity to provide geographic support for political/administrative boundaries, census data, etc...the non-combat stuff. I gave up long ago trying to explain how pop displacement tracking might help them know something about the place and people, or how, regardless of what system is used, land records and cadestral info tell as much as anthropology (people always record land transactions---even the bad guys).
(I would say non-mil stuff, but the military is so heavily involved in things civilian that the civ/mil distinction is one without a difference).
Send me an email if you would like a copy of the Ninewa ppt, or an accurate admin/pol map of Northern Iraq. (Too big to post).
Don't get me started on the crappy population/demographic data (my actual expertise). There are soldiers on the ground who knew more about how many people were where than the big shot decision-makers, but no systematic mechanism to collect and consolidate the data for real-time use. (Sure, you'll here from some spooky people here who might suggest it's somewhere else. Been there, done that. It ain't. Just a big intel/decision gap).
In a recent report, the Kagans cited that Afghanistan has a pop of between 26 and 30 million. The pundits usually say 33 million. They all make this stuff up and cross-cite each other. If the Afghan pop is plus or minus 7 million, how accurate do you think the local pop data is.
Bookmarks