A review of Directorate S from Major Amin, now up at Brownpundits.
https://www.brownpundits.com/2019/02...directorate-s/
Excerpt:
What we have is an interesting narrative but no subtle analysis. Passing references to US lack of strategic insight but no details.
What Coll fails to admit or openly state is that the entire US war in Afghanistan was an exercise in massive self deception . Since the US lacked the strategic resolution to confront the Pakistani state , it fooled itself and its public with vague entities like Al Qaeda, which never was a serious player in Af Pak.
Coll refuses to see the hard and harsh picture that 90 % US casualties in actual fighting were caused by ISI proxies and not Al Qaeda.
It is a harsh admission that whole nations and states and this includes a super power like USA can go on deceiving themselves and their public and Steve Coll's massive and exhaustive gargantuan book offers no definite conclusions.
Bookmarks