Those of you following issues of cyberwar likely subscribe to the Dailydave Newsletter, and Dave Aitel--a veteran of the NSA and CEO of Immunity, Inc.--recently posted a link to a work-in-progress presentation entitled "The Three Cyber-War Fallacies." In it, Aitel seeks to debunk the following three claims:

1. Cyberwar is asymmetric.
2. Cyberwar is non-kinetic.
3. Cyberwar is not attributable.
These are all provocative claims worth examining, so I wanted to see if anyone here wanted to debate one or more of these. At any rate, read through the presentation. It makes for interesting reading even in its unfinished form.