Dear CavGuy,

Thanks for your continued interest in our work. We're looking forward to reading your reply in International Organization.

For those who are interested, I'd simply note that we posted the replication data, including the exact codes for statistical replication, on my website in April (the article was published in January 2009). In January, we also posted the codebook, supplemental analyses, and cases (286 of them).
http://www.princeton.edu/~jlyall/

Though IO does not have a replication policy, we hoped that this dataset will be used, and improved upon, by other scholars, and so we released it. By making it available to all parties (it's been downloaded more than 50 times since posting), we aim to provide a public good.

Are there limitations with these data? Of course. But rather than flaming us anonymously on a chat forum, perhaps it would be a good idea to open the dataset, look at what we've done, and then make efforts to improve upon it. That way, we all win, and we move the study of COIN forward.

Anyways, just wanted to set the record straight.