OK, I know this is a touchy subject, but Ken White's post here, does merit further examination in my opinion.

There have been numerous, quite well researched opinions, data and papers, that not everyone fights, when required to do so.

What we seem to know is
  • Most men will fight, given good leadership, thus good leaders and NCOs make a huge difference.
  • In the absence of such leadership, they will simply revert to doing the minimum required by appearances.
  • 3-5% will run or simply play no useful part.

I do not want anyone to start airing dirty laundry, but I think this issue might be usefully discussed.