SMALL WARS COUNCIL
Go Back   Small Wars Council > Small Wars Participants & Stakeholders > Historians

Historians The practice of history, and historical analysis. See FAQ for where to discuss history relevant to other forums.

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 05-22-2017   #241
SWJ Blog
Council Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Posts: 10,907
Default Was Vietnam Winnable?

Was Vietnam Winnable?

Entry Excerpt:



--------
Read the full post and make any comments at the SWJ Blog.
This forum is a feed only and is closed to user comments.
SWJ Blog is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 05-29-2017   #242
SWJ Blog
Council Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Posts: 10,907
Default Ken Burns Talks About the Vietnam War, the Wall and His New Documentary

Ken Burns Talks About the Vietnam War, the Wall and His New Documentary

Entry Excerpt:



--------
Read the full post and make any comments at the SWJ Blog.
This forum is a feed only and is closed to user comments.
SWJ Blog is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-22-2017   #243
Azor
Council Member
 
Join Date: Aug 2015
Posts: 813
Default Could the United States Have Really Won the Vietnam War?

By Robert Farley at War is Boring: https://warisboring.com/could-the-un...on-in-vietnam/

Introduction:

Quote:
Mark Moyar, the scholar of U.S. foreign and military policy, recently had the opportunity to update an older argument on the viability of the Vietnam War.

Moyar argues that the historical consensus on the war is wrong on several points, and that in fact the United States could have won the war and preserved the Saigon government at acceptable cost.

While Moyar’s argument is worth consideration, he still fails to make his case against the long-standing consensus on the war.
Moyar's key points:
  • South Vietnam was a viable state by 1972, afflicted but not overwhelmed by insurgency
  • Local Communist forces in South Vietnam had been mortally wounded in 1968
  • With U.S. support, South Vietnam could blunt and even defeat North Vietnamese offensives
  • Saigon was far more democratic and less repressive than Hanoi
  • The war was less unpopular in the U.S. at the time than it is presently

Farley’s “realities”:
  • South Vietnam could not survive on its own in the way of South Korea
  • Hanoi was unified whereas Saigon was prone to infighting
  • The U.S. could not have stopped North Vietnamese aggression
  • The war was unpopular enough that Nixon faced no opposition in 1972 for abandoning South Vietnam, and Ford could not generate any support for re-engagement in 1975
  • The U.S. could have militarily won by invading and occupying North Vietnam or have merely remained engaged in the South indefinitely, but both options would have been very costly politically and materially
Azor is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-22-2017   #244
Bob's World
Council Member
 
Bob's World's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Florida
Posts: 2,706
Default

Gotta disagree with Mark, as he is arguing based upon the US narrative on the war, rather than the Vietnamese reality. The "states" of North and South Vietnam were legal fictions created by the US in an effort to deny the Vietnamese people the victory they had won to remove the French and attain a self determined government. The victors came from across Vietnam and were forced to withdraw into what became North Vietnam. Meanwhile the insurgency continued in the Maoist model of ebb and flow until they finally prevailed. Sure, we could have delayed their independence even longer than the 30 years we did, but it would have happened eventually. Conflicts are what they are, caring little for how they are named or perceived by various parties. The US completely misunderstood and mis- defined that conflict. A mistake we are repeating in a few places currently as well.
__________________
Robert C. Jones
Intellectus Supra Scientia
(Understanding is more important than Knowledge)

"The modern COIN mindset is when one arrogantly goes to some foreign land and attempts to make those who live there a lesser version of one's self. The FID mindset is when one humbly goes to some foreign land and seeks first to understand, and then to help in some small way for those who live there to be the best version of their own self." Colonel Robert C. Jones, US Army Special Forces (Retired)
Bob's World is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-23-2017   #245
davidbfpo
Council Member
 
davidbfpo's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: UK
Posts: 11,367
Default Two Colonels said

There are a number of SWJ articles on this question and two caught my attention:

1) In 2009'A Better Understanding of the Vietnam War'byColonel Gian Gentile and there is a telling quote:
Quote:
...the war could [not] have been 'won' in any meaningful sense at a moral or material cost most Americans deemed acceptable.
Link:http://smallwarsjournal.com/jrnl/art...he-vietnam-war

2) In 2011 'Vietnam Postmortem: A Senseless Strategy' by David Maxwell, that is a pointer to a Parameters article by Colonel John Collins. This led to thirty-five comments. Amidst them is one by Ken White, cited in part, with my emphasis:
Quote:
If we cannot discuss history and current activities then we may have to fight them again as you say -- but I do not believe it will be a like it or not problem. It will be a choice on our part. I for one submit that Vietnam was a mistake in all aspect
Link:http://smallwarsjournal.com/blog/vie...eless-strategy
__________________
davidbfpo
davidbfpo is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 07-02-2017   #246
davidbfpo
Council Member
 
davidbfpo's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: UK
Posts: 11,367
Default Might this PBS series help understanding?

Maybe timely a new PBS series is due, by Ken Burns and The Guardian has a report. The headline and sub-title:
Quote:
Ken Burns returns to take on Vietnam – 'a war we have consciously ignored' Burns’s new 10-part, 18-hour epic film covers the conflict from all sides, and hopes to ‘shape more courageous conversations about what took place’
Quote:
The war in south-east Asia is now the subject of an epic 10-part, 18-hour series by Ken Burns and Lynn Novick. Burns is America’s premier documentary film-maker....
The series, which premieres on the Public Broadcasting Service (PBS) on 17 September in the US and will be released in full on DVD in the UK, includes rarely seen archival footage, photographs, TV broadcasts, home movies and secret audio recordings from the Kennedy, Johnson and Nixon administrations, as well as music of the period....
Link:https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/...oreign-policy?
__________________
davidbfpo

Last edited by davidbfpo; 07-02-2017 at 09:33 PM. Reason: 1857v
davidbfpo is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 09-04-2017   #247
SWJ Blog
Council Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Posts: 10,907
Default 7 Important Weapons Used By the United States in the Vietnam War

7 Important Weapons Used By the United States in the Vietnam War

Entry Excerpt:



--------
Read the full post and make any comments at the SWJ Blog.
This forum is a feed only and is closed to user comments.
SWJ Blog is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 09-16-2017   #248
SWJ Blog
Council Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Posts: 10,907
Default Documentary Review - Ken Burns and Lynn Novick's ‘The Vietnam War’

Documentary Review - Ken Burns and Lynn Novick's ‘The Vietnam War’

Entry Excerpt:



--------
Read the full post and make any comments at the SWJ Blog.
This forum is a feed only and is closed to user comments.
SWJ Blog is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 09-17-2017   #249
SWJ Blog
Council Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Posts: 10,907
Default Ken Burns’ Vietnam War Docu-Series Premieres Today

Ken Burns’ Vietnam War Docu-Series Premieres Today

Entry Excerpt:



--------
Read the full post and make any comments at the SWJ Blog.
This forum is a feed only and is closed to user comments.
SWJ Blog is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 09-21-2017   #250
SWJ Blog
Council Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Posts: 10,907
Default Navy Completes Vietnam War Book Series

Navy Completes Vietnam War Book Series

Entry Excerpt:



--------
Read the full post and make any comments at the SWJ Blog.
This forum is a feed only and is closed to user comments.
SWJ Blog is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 10-01-2017   #251
SWJ Blog
Council Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Posts: 10,907
Default The Documentary “The Vietnam War”: Artistic License as History

The Documentary “The Vietnam War”: Artistic License as History

Entry Excerpt:



--------
Read the full post and make any comments at the SWJ Blog.
This forum is a feed only and is closed to user comments.
SWJ Blog is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 10-30-2017   #252
SWJ Blog
Council Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Posts: 10,907
Default Honors and Errors: The Burns-Novick Vietnam War Documentary

Honors and Errors: The Burns-Novick Vietnam War Documentary

Entry Excerpt:



--------
Read the full post and make any comments at the SWJ Blog.
This forum is a feed only and is closed to user comments.
SWJ Blog is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 1 Week Ago   #253
SWJ Blog
Council Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Posts: 10,907
Default Was Vietnam Winnable? A New Book Suggests Yes and Offers Advice for the War in Afghan

Was Vietnam Winnable? A New Book Suggests Yes and Offers Advice for the War in Afghanistan.

Entry Excerpt:



--------
Read the full post and make any comments at the SWJ Blog.
This forum is a feed only and is closed to user comments.
SWJ Blog is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 1 Week Ago   #254
SWJ Blog
Council Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Posts: 10,907
Default Lessons and Echoes from the War in Vietnam

Lessons and Echoes from the War in Vietnam

Entry Excerpt:



--------
Read the full post and make any comments at the SWJ Blog.
This forum is a feed only and is closed to user comments.
SWJ Blog is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 3 Days Ago   #255
SWJ Blog
Council Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Posts: 10,907
Default Honors and Errors: The Burns Vietnam Documentary

Honors and Errors: The Burns Vietnam Documentary

Entry Excerpt:



--------
Read the full post and make any comments at the SWJ Blog.
This forum is a feed only and is closed to user comments.
SWJ Blog is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 2 Days Ago   #256
davidbfpo
Council Member
 
davidbfpo's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: UK
Posts: 11,367
Default Moderator at work

I have merged twelve threads into this main historians thread, prompted by the SWJ article 'Honors and Errors: The Burns Vietnam Documentary'. Which now has 255 posts and 223,969 views.

There are two large, closed separate threads:The Advisory or Advisor Challenge which has 102 posts and 113k views; Vietnam collection (lessons plus) with 140 posts and 122k views.

If you search using Vietnam as a thread title there are thirty or so threads, with sufficiently different themes best left alone.
__________________
davidbfpo

Last edited by davidbfpo; 2 Days Ago at 10:21 AM.
davidbfpo is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply

Bookmarks

Tags
cia, coin, cold war, counter insurgency, counterinsurgency, history, indo-china, intelligence, nation building, pacification, rural pacification, strategy, surogate warfare, united states, us army, us marines, vietnam, vietnam war, war

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Vietnam collection (lessons plus) SWJED Training & Education 140 06-27-2014 05:40 AM
Gurkha beheads Taliban... Rifleman OEF - Afghanistan 22 10-30-2010 03:00 AM
War is War Michael C Futurists & Theorists 101 10-09-2010 07:23 PM
McCuen: a "missing" thread? Cavguy Futurists & Theorists 18 07-20-2010 05:56 PM


All times are GMT. The time now is 05:54 PM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.9. ©2000 - 2018, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Registered Users are solely responsible for their messages.
Operated by, and site design © 2005-2009, Small Wars Foundation