Quote Originally Posted by wm View Post
I submit that the problem with this discussion of morality is that it is based on a notion that rights are primary.
Well, nothing I've said is inconsistent with a Kantian conception of rights. And holding these rights to be primary in this context doesn't necessarily require a consequentialist appeal.

Quote Originally Posted by wm View Post
Universal truths are unconditional. So are duties.
Perhaps, but duties are not the only source of moral value. And certainly not the only one relevant to the ethics of war.